A few weeks ago, the Inside Track took a look at the complex legislative issue of preemption. This week we go a bit further to explore how preemption has been used to affect food policy and what advocates need to know about the issue.
We talked with Jennifer Pomeranz, an assistant professor at Temple University’s Department of Public Health and Center for Obesity Research and Prevention, to learn more.
Preemption happens, in short, when “the industry does not want to deal with what they call a patchwork of different laws,” Pomeranz explained. “So they try to get laws passed at the federal or state levels that preempt the local laws with weaker standards.”
One prominent case of preemption in food policy has been the fight over menu labeling. Municipalities in California such as San Francisco and Santa Clara faced food-industry lawsuits and found themselves at odds with the state government when industry lobbyists sought a bill that would preempt those rules.
In Tennessee, when Nashville instituted menu labeling, the state legislature responded by passing a law saying no municipal health department--the city agency that regulated menu labeling in Nashville--could institute such a policy.
Sometimes preemption is done, well, preemptively; Pomeranz noted that when New York City sought to limit serving sizes of sugary drinks, state lawmakers in Mississippi, where no such limit existed, sought to make sure it never would by passing the so-called “anti-Bloomberg bill,” which preempted sugary-drink limits in any of its municipalities.
And sometimes it is “sneaked” into unexpected places: When the city of Cleveland passed a ban on trans fats, the Ohio State Legislature preempted that – not via a food policy bill, but via the state budget appropriations process.
For advocates seeking to better understand the issue or fight cases of preemption, there are two keys: timely awareness and an understanding of where to draw the line of compromise.
First of all, Pomeranz notes, “advocates really need to get a lawyer to research whether [a given law is] preempted already, because if it is, they will lose.”
She suggested that activists concerned about preemption in a given law should push right away for a savings clause, which expressly states that a law does not preempt state or local control. Alternatively, a minimum requirement in a law can keep standards where advocates want them to be.
“And then they have to stay up on it,” Pomeranz says. “Things are put in at the last minute and sometimes it’s hard to find out about that.”
Another problem comes when activists wedded to seeing their goals become law accept preemption as a part of getting that done. She noted that this caused a rift among advocates when the school lunch program came up for reauthorization five years ago. The bill was to have included a preemption clause saying states couldn’t make laws stronger than the federal law. This would have voided laws such as Connecticut’s ban on sugary beverages, she noted.
“A lot of advocates stopped supporting it and it caused a divide … [but] in the long run we were right,” Pomeranz said. “That’s what you want, stronger requirements without preemption.”
“For advocates and stakeholders and the grassroots, this should be part of the conversation from the beginning — what they’re willing to give up.”
Donna Brutkoski authored this article.
THIS WEBSITE IS INTENDED FOR USE BY PERSONS OF MAJORITY AGE AND IS GOVERNED BY THE LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
Office of State Advocacy
American Heart Association
7272 Greenville Avenue
Dallas, TX 75231
Compliance with Laws
Users of the Services shall abide by all applicable international, federal, state and local laws, including, but not limited to, those pertaining to libel, slander, defamation, trade libel, product disparagement, harassment, invasion of privacy, and copyright and trademark infringement.
Disclaimer of Warranties and Limitation of Liability
THE WEBSITE IS PROVIDED TO YOU "AS IS." THE ASSOCIATION DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, WHETHER EXPRESS, IMPLIED OR STATUTORY (INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, WARRANTIES OF TITLE OR NON INFRINGEMENT, OR ANY WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE). THE ASSOCIATION DOES NOT WARRANT OR GUARANTEE THE ACCURACY, COMPLETENESS, CORRECTNESS, TIMELINESS, OR USEFULNESS OF ANY INFORMATION, PROGRAMS, PRODUCTS, OR SERVICES OR OTHER MATERIAL PROVIDED THROUGH THE WEB SITE. THE ASSOCIATION MAKES NO WARRANTY OR GUARANTEE THAT THE WEB SITE WILL BE UNINTERRUPTED, TIMELY, SECURE, OR ERROR FREE. IN NO EVENT WILL THE ASSOCIATION BE LIABLE TO THE USER OR ANYONE ELSE FOR ANY DECISION MADE OR ACTION TAKEN IN RELIANCE UPON THE INFORMATION CONTAINED ON OR PROVIDED THROUGH THE WEB SITE, NOR FOR ANY INCIDENTAL, INDIRECT, SPECIAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES.
Copyright and Ownership.
All trademarks, service marks and trade names of the American Heart Association (collectively, the "AHA Marks") are trademarks or registered trademarks of the American Heart Association or its licensors, vendors, agents and/or content providers. You may not use, copy, reproduce, republish, upload, post, transmit, distribute or modify the AHA Marks in any way, including in advertising or publicity pertaining to distribution of materials on the Website, without the Association’s prior written consent. The use of the AHA Marks on any other website or network computer environment is not allowed.
Services and Submissions
For content that you provide to the Network that is covered by intellectual property rights, you grant the Association a non-exclusive, transferable, sub-licensable, royalty-free, worldwide license to use, in any form now existing or hereafter discovered, any content that you post on or in connection with the Services.
To the extent that the Association makes available to you through the Services (or otherwise) "widgets" to obtain access to Content from the Services (collectively, the “Widgets”), you agree as a condition to accessing and using such items that you will not use the Widgets for any commercial use, without the prior written consent of the Association. Prohibited commercial uses include, but are not limited to, sale of access to the Services on another web site and use of the Services for the purpose of gaining advertising or subscription revenue.
Member Account, Password and Security.
Some of the Services may require that you create/receive a password and account designation before using the Services. See “Registration” below. You are responsible for maintaining the confidentiality of any such password and account, and are fully responsible for all activities that occur under your password or account. If you allow third parties to access the Services through your username and password, you will defend and indemnify the Association and its Representatives from and against any liability, costs or damages arising out of claims or suits based upon or relating to such access and use. You agree to immediately notify the Network as set forth above of any unauthorized use of your password or account or any other breach of security related to the Services of which you are aware.
Unlawful or Prohibited Use.
As a condition of your use of the Services, you will not use the Services for any purpose that is unlawful or prohibited by these Terms of Service or is otherwise prohibited under applicable law. You may not use the Services in any manner that could damage, disable, overburden, or impair the Services or interfere with any other party's use and enjoyment of the Services. You may not attempt to gain unauthorized access to any Services.
Guidelines. Be respectful of others -- do not post or send:
1. Content or communications that are unlawful, harmful, threatening, abusive, harassing, tortuous, defamatory, vulgar, sexually explicit, obscene, pornographic, libelous, invasive of another's privacy, hateful, or racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable;
2. Content or communications that falsely state or otherwise misrepresent your identity, affiliation with the Association, or any person or other entity;
3. Confidential business or personal information, or content that infringes any trademark, trade secret, copyright or other proprietary rights of any party;
4. Content or communications that make available unsolicited or unauthorized advertising, promotional materials, sweepstakes, junk mail, spam, chain letters, pyramid schemes, or any similar form of solicitation;
5. Content or communications that are fraudulent, false, inaccurate or misleading;
6. Content or communications that violate any law, ordinance or regulation; that promotes illegal activities; that is harmful to minors; or
7. Links to files that contain viruses, Trojan horses, worms, time bombs, cancelbots, corrupted files, or any other similar software or programs that may damage the operation of another's computer or property of another.
A user’s ability to access to the Services is based on that user’s level of user authorization.
Unregistered users of the Network have limited access to the Services. They can see public information on the website, including blog posts, educational resources, and the Leader Directory. Unregistered users may also contact people in the Leader Directory individually, using the social media links (Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn) shared by the Leader. Unregistered users may also, subject to these Terms of Service, embed Widgets on other web sites, but they cannot customize the Widgets or have access to any of the contact information or other data generated by the use of such Widgets.
There are two types of registered users of the Network:
Supporters are people who affirmatively opt-in to participate in the Network by filling out a registration form (“Contacts”) or completing an online action. They can take action on alerts and view public information, including blog posts, educational resources, and the Leader Directory. Supporters may also contact people in the Leader Directory individually, using the social media links (Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn) shared by the Leader.
Network Leaders are Contacts who have completed a registration form requesting Network Leader status and who have been approved by the Network based on a) a demonstrated organizational commitment to the Network Mission, and b) a track record of having done work to engage or organize others (“Network Leaders”). In addition to retaining all the user privileges of Supporters, Network Leaders can create public profiles to share in the Leader Directory. They can, subject to these Terms of Service, embed Widgets on other websites and request the set-up of action alerts and email launches to the network through Voices for Healthy Kids Action Center staff.
Access and Interference
You agree not to circumvent, disable or otherwise interfere with security-related features of the Services or features that prevent or restrict use or copying of any content or enforce limitations on use of the Services or the Content therein. You agree that you will not use any bot, crawler, harvester, indexer, robot, spider, scraper or any other automated means to access, compile, read or gather content from the Services automatically. Additionally, you agree that you will not: (a) take any action that, in our sole discretion, imposes, or may impose an unreasonable or disproportionately large load on our infrastructure; (b) interfere or attempt to interfere with the proper working of the Services or any activities conducted on the Services; or (c) bypass any measures we may use to prevent or restrict access to the Services.
You agree to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the Association and the Representatives from and against any and all losses, damages, liabilities and costs of every nature incurred by any of them in connection with any claim, damage or loss related to or arising out of: your use of the Services, any assistance or Services provided by us or the Representatives to you, any alleged unauthorized use of the Services by you, or any breach or alleged breach by you of these Terms of Service. You agree to cooperate fully in the defense of any of the foregoing. We reserve the right, at our own expense, to control exclusively the defense of any matter otherwise subject to indemnification by you and you will not settle any matter without our prior written consent. Your obligation to indemnify, defend and hold harmless shall be limited to the extent that you are afforded sovereign immunity under applicable federal, state or local laws. In such cases where your obligation to indemnify may be limited due to the requirements of federal, state or local laws, you shall be responsible for the ordinary negligent acts and omissions of your agents and employees causing harm to persons not a party to these Terms of Service.
In the event that you have a dispute with one or more other users of the Services, you release the Association and Representatives from any and all claims, demands and damages (actual and consequential) of every kind and nature, known and unknown, suspected and unsuspected, disclosed and undisclosed, arising out of or in any way connected with such disputes.
Applicable Law and Jurisdiction
This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the State of Texas, without regard to its conflict of laws rules. Venue for any cause of action arising under this Agreement shall be proper in Dallas, Dallas County, Texas.
Electronic Communications; Binding and Entire Agreement
If any provision of this Agreement is held to be illegal, invalid, or unenforceable under present or future laws, then such provision shall be fully severable, this Agreement shall be construed and enforced as if such illegal, invalid, or unenforceable provision had never comprised a part of this Agreement, and the remaining provisions of this Agreement shall remain in full force and effect and shall not be affected by the illegal, invalid, or unenforceable provision or by its severance from this Agreement.
Applicable Law: This Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the State of Texas, without regard to its conflict of laws rules. Venue for any cause of action arising under this Agreement shall be proper in Dallas, Dallas County, Texas.
Waiver: The terms of this Agreement cannot be waived or modified except by the Association. There are no representations, warranties or covenants other than those set forth in this Agreement, which sets forth the entire understanding between the parties. The User's rights and obligations hereunder are personal to User and cannot be assigned, sublicensed or otherwise transferred or encumbered by User or by operation of law. Any such assignment in contravention of the foregoing shall be null and void and of no force and effect.
Leaders are people who are actively working - either professionally or as volunteers - to change policies and environments to help children eat better and be more active. We use the following criteria to evaluate whether to approve an applicant for Leader status with the Voices for Healthy Kids Action Center.
Do you meet the criteria below? If so, register as a Leader here. There is no cost to be a Leader.
At least one item must be checked within each of the following two categories:
1. Applicant is focused on changing policies and environments
They are working on one of Voices for Healthy Kid's six issue areas:
Ensure foods and beverages in schools meet dietary guidelines
Expand community access to high quality food
Expand physical activity programs in and out of school
Improve built environment in communities to increase physical activity
Use pricing strategies to promote purchase of healthier foods
Use regulation/policy to reduce youth exposure to unhealthy food marketing
They are working on other obesity-related issues, such as:
Their primary focus is working on individual behavior (e.g., teaching kids about food, play, etc.), but they have access to organizations that could provide opportunities to change environments, such as
Public Health Agencies
Their project is commercial, but contributes positively to changing policies and environments, such as:
2. Applicant is organizing others or contributing to organizing efforts
They are organizing others by:
Providing volunteer opportunities
Building contact lists of supporters to engage in advocacy
They provide support to organizations or leaders doing work changing policies and environments, such as:
They are a leader in a governmental body that may be the target of organizing efforts to change policies and environments, such as a:
Federal or state agency
Mayor or other local executive office
Federal, state, county or local public health department
Federal, state, county or transportation department
Federal, state or local education agency or school board
If the applicant claims to work for an organization, at least one item must be checked below:
3. Applicant works for an organization:
Has an email address that matches the domain of the organization they list
Is listed on the organization website as staff
The Voices for Healthy Kids Action Center is looking for bloggers who can write about issues that matter to our community on a regular basis. If you would like to be considered for this network, please check this box.